top of page

The Thin Line Between Lead Generation and Privacy Invasion: A Case Study from Charlotte's Real Estate Scene

In the competitive realm of real estate, the drive to secure listings can sometimes lead to tactics that blur ethical lines.

A recent episode in Charlotte, highlighted through a Facebook post in a REALTOR network group, provides a vivid example of this and has sparked a crucial conversation about professional boundaries and respect for privacy.

The Situation

The situation unfolded at a recently withdrawn listing, where the sellers, represented by their agent, chose to withdraw their listing for personal reasons. The plan was to relist the property later. However, this decision led to an unexpected and unwelcome development. Other real estate agents, eyeing an opportunity, began to engage in aggressive lead-generation tactics. They lingered outside the property, eagerly waiting to approach the sellers when they stepped outside their home to convince them to relist with them.

Community Reaction: Shock and Disapproval

The original post and the following comments from fellow agents expressed shock and disapproval of such tactics:

"Agents have been sitting outside their home for over an hour waiting for them to walk outside…" highlighted the disturbing extent of the intrusion.
Another comment, "Imagine if it were your parents or grandparents and random agents were harassing them. Yikes," emphasizes empathy and the need for respect.
The shift from traditional door-knocking to what some called "STALKING" was noted as particularly disturbing: "Lingering outside of someone’s house is disturbing!!!! I’m sorry they had to experience this….."
The view that door-knocking is outdated was also expressed: "IMHO I don’t think door knocking is appropriate this day and age either. Home is your sanctuary…"
The incident was seen as "Ridiculous and embarrassing to our industry!" reflecting the concern for the industry's reputation.
A simple yet powerful reaction, "What??? And that’s what gives all realtors a bad name," underlines the broader impact of such behaviors.
The seriousness of the matter was further underscored by one agent who mentioned making a "non urgent police call" if they noticed an unknown car in front of their property.

Ethical Considerations in Lead Generation

This incident brings to the forefront several ethical considerations:

  1. Respect for Privacy: The need for agents to respect the privacy and decisions of homeowners cannot be overstated.

  2. Professional Conduct: While seeking listings is a natural part of an agent's work, there must be a line that differentiates persistence from intrusion.

  3. Reputation and Trust: Such actions can significantly damage the reputation of the profession and erode public trust in real estate agents.

  4. Alternatives to Aggressive Tactics: The industry needs to lean more towards respectful and less intrusive methods of lead generation.


This incident serves as a poignant reminder of the delicate balance between aggressive lead generation and respecting homeowner privacy. As real estate professionals, it's crucial to remember that our actions reflect on the entire industry. Upholding ethical standards and treating potential clients with respect and dignity is not just a professional obligation, but a fundamental aspect of maintaining the integrity and trustworthiness of the real estate industry.

What do you think of this agent's actions? Sound off in the comments or discuss it with a colleague in an upcoming CE Class!

863 views1 comment

1 Comment

This situation can be distressing for sellers and may violate their privacy.

bottom of page